Solved

How to differentiate between Mobile Web and Desktop Web (and Tablet as a bonus)


Hi all, 

Is there an equivalent of Google Analytics Device Category in Amplitude? Here’s a post about how GA does it.

I’m looking to segment our Web platform events and user properties further by Mobile vs Desktop (and Tablet as a bonus). 

Here's some Amplitude community topics, that I've found so far, and I think it requires segmenting by a combination of OS and Device type, but I can’t find a clean way of doing it.

 

Many thanks in advance. 

Raul

 

Similar topics. 
https://community.amplitude.com/instrumentation-and-data-management-57/amplitude-device-type-and-device-family-fields-129
https://community.amplitude.com/instrumentation-and-data-management-57/counting-users-who-have-done-event-on-mobile-desktop-584
https://community.amplitude.com/instrumentation-and-data-management-57/how-to-get-separate-stats-for-web-and-mobile-app-version-names-368

icon

Best answer by Maya 10 October 2022, 11:28

View original

11 replies

Userlevel 1

Hi Raul,

 

At this time, our SDK does not have a default user property that distinguishes events from web and mobile traffic. In case you can track these differences on your end, you can create a custom user property that will indicate whether an event is from a web or mobile source.

While there isn’t straight forward possibility to do so in Amplitude, we would indeed suggest that you use 'OS' and ‘Device Family’ user properties to come closer to these results without additional instrumentation (only captured if you are using the Amplitude SDKs to send data). Please note I would not position this as a solution but as an attempt to get close to these results.

 

Many of your mobile users have the word "mobile" in the name of their OS, and you can segment for events where with "OS contains Mobile" and "OS does not contain Mobile". Additionally, you can use “Device Family” to check if it contains “tablet”. 

 

 

Things to be aware of:

  • The OS = "Chrome 105" would apply for mobile and desktop
  • The '[Amplitude] Device family' and '[Amplitude] Device type' values based on a custom mapping that we do whenever we encounter new devices. Sometimes, these might not be added to the existing mappings. You can request a new device to be added as mentioned here


Hope this helps! If you have anymore questions, please let me know!

Userlevel 1

Hi guys,

Just chiming in here as I think the solution you have offered is a real hacky/bandaid workaround. I often find myself trying to achieve what Raul has mentioned in Amplitude. 

I think this would be a very worthwhile default library user trait to have!

Thanks

I agree with @toby_c5k , this solution is too much of a bandaid that’s prone to error, and does not give us an easy solution on par with other standard tools in the field (i.e. Google Analytics).

Badge

Hey @Maya ,

I completely agree with @ascar and @toby_c5k:

I do get various questions regarding usage of our product differentiating tablet vs phone from our product owners and it would be great to answer those with with confidence.

Any chance this categorization could land on amplitude’s roadmap?
 

Userlevel 5
Badge +9

Hey @Micha - I added this (and a similar item regarding browser types) as a request to Amplitude’s ideas board which the product team has eyes on. Feel free to upvote!

 

Lol it’s amazing there’s no such thing in 2023 

Badge

Absolute table-stakes functionality for a web analytics tool. Embarrassing. 

Userlevel 5
Badge +9

Keep in mind this tool comes from an initial standpoint of product analytics, it’s only in recent times that it’s truly moving into also covering what many of us know as digital/ web/ marketing analytics. This of course takes time, so given how far ahead Amplitude is in the behavioural measurement/ insight space than many of the established digital analytics vendors (coupled with the great UI and integrations for easier data activation), I’m sure we can all afford them some patience to build some of the dimensions that are taken for granted in GA/ Adobe. Or for those that can’t afford the patience, there’s always the option of GA4 where you can get device category natively and instead have reams of fun with the widely publicised, lengthy list of UI and sampling issues.

Badge

Here’s how we set this up as a derived property, couldn’t find anything else already written up on the forums. Not perfect but it appears to work. Still would love to see this provided by Amplitude.

IF(
<device family property> contains (
'tab',
'ipad',
'kindle'
),
'tablet',
IF(
<OS property> contains (
'mobile'
),
'mobile',
IF (
<OS property> contains (
'none'
),
'unknown',
'desktop'
)
)
)

 

Badge

@dangrainger can you explain why I can’t see “derived properties” on my Tracking Plan—>Properties screen?

Userlevel 7
Badge +10

@Cameron Ross 

What plan are you on? Derived properties is available to users on Enterprise plans or those with the Govern add-on.

Reply