Segmentation, performed by two segments: 1. a cohort with user property "A" 2. user property "A".

In a segmentation chart with custom date range “Since Dec 7, 2021”, 
on the right hand side I have set up two segments:

1. where “Cohort” = “Cohort Blue”
(Cohort Blue is configured as: The users who ..had user property "A" = “Blue”, anytime since Dec 7, 2021)

2. where "A" = “Blue”

So the only difference is that 1. is a saved cohort with user property “A” = “Blue” in the where clause and 2. have this user property “A” = “Blue” directly in the where clause, why do I get different result when the users should effectively be the same?

Let’s say I have chosen “Any Active Event” on the left hand side, then a line chart will most of the time always have a higher count of “Uniques” for the 1. the cohort segment vs 2. the where segment. They do however, tend to converge over time, but the difference is quite large in the beginning.

Why don’t they produce the same result?

Below is an example graph:

Grateful for any help, explanation!

Thanks in advance,
Nils